The Rundown - The Impact of Minimum Wages on Smaller Nonprofits - June 16, 2023
Those organizations there to serve others are feeling the pinch.
Minimum Wage in America
Over thirty states here in the United States have a state-imposed minimum wage that is higher than the current federal standard. The current federal standard was adopted in 2009 and currently stands at $7.25/hour. Here in Ohio, our state-wide minimum currently stands at $10.10/hour. That rate is set by the State Department of Commerce and is loosely indexed to inflation rates. The rate has grown greatly over the last few years and it has some smaller nonprofit organizations worried about their long term financial sustainability.
Proponents for better minimum wage legislation have been arguing for its ability to ensure fair compensation for workers, while opponents highlight the potential negative consequences, particularly for small businesses. However, the impact of minimum wage legislation on small rural nonprofit organizations has received less attention. Let’s explore the effects of minimum wage legislation on these organizations, specifically in the context of rural areas where socioeconomic dynamics and available resources may differ from urban counterparts.
Importance of Small Rural Nonprofit Organizations: Small rural nonprofit organizations play a crucial role in fostering community development, providing essential services, and addressing local needs. These organizations often operate on limited budgets, relying heavily on volunteers and donations to fulfill their missions. In rural areas, they face unique challenges, including limited access to funding, a smaller labor pool, and lower average wages. Understanding the impact of minimum wage legislation on these organizations is essential to ensure their sustainability and effectiveness.
Benefits of Minimum Wage Legislation: Minimum wage legislation aims to protect workers from exploitation and provide them with a living wage. By raising the minimum wage, workers can meet basic needs, potentially reducing poverty levels and improving overall well-being. Higher wages may also lead to increased consumer spending, benefiting local businesses, including nonprofit organizations. Additionally, better compensation can enhance employee morale and retention, promoting a stable workforce within nonprofit organizations.
Challenges for Small Rural Nonprofit Organizations: While the intentions behind minimum wage legislation are laudable, implementing it in small rural nonprofit organizations presents unique challenges. These organizations often operate with tight budgets, relying on part-time or volunteer workers. Mandating higher wages may strain their financial resources, leading to reduced services or even closure. Nonprofits may face difficulty competing with for-profit businesses for talent, as they often cannot offer higher wages or benefits.
Financial Implications: Small rural nonprofit organizations typically operate on thin margins, relying on careful budgeting and efficient resource allocation. The introduction of minimum wage legislation can significantly impact their financial stability. Higher wages often translate into increased operational costs, affecting the ability to allocate resources towards program delivery and community initiatives. Nonprofits may face difficult decisions, such as cutting staff, reducing services, or increasing fundraising efforts to compensate for the additional expenses.
Impact on Volunteer-Based Workforce: Rural nonprofit organizations often rely on volunteers who generously donate their time and skills. Minimum wage legislation can inadvertently discourage volunteers by creating the perception that their contributions are undervalued. Concerns about wage disparities may dissuade individuals from volunteering, resulting in a shortage of manpower. The loss of volunteers can strain these organizations, reducing their capacity to serve the community effectively.
Collaboration and Resource Sharing: In response to the challenges posed by minimum wage legislation, small rural nonprofit organizations can explore collaborative strategies. Sharing resources, such as office spaces, equipment, or staff, can help minimize the financial burden. Collaborative efforts also foster stronger partnerships within the community, enabling organizations to pool their resources and amplify their impact. By working together, rural nonprofits can continue to provide vital services while navigating the challenges brought about by minimum wage legislation.
Policy Considerations: To mitigate the potential negative impacts of minimum wage legislation on small rural nonprofit organizations, policymakers should consider implementing measures tailored to the unique circumstances of these organizations. This may include providing financial incentives or subsidies to offset increased labor costs, offering flexibility in compliance requirements, or supporting skill development and capacity building within the sector.
A Problem That is Not Going Away
As I think about minimum wage legislation, I can’t help but think about those forces that are driving up wages. In my mind, wage increases aren’t so much the product of minimum wage legislation that is on the books, but it is the wages being offered for workers by other employers. Traditional minimum wage jobs (such as fast food restaurants) are well above $15.00/hour as they work to attract and retain the talent they have on their staff.
I tend to believe these increases are due in large part to the labor force participation rate.
The labor force participation rate, while slowly moving up, is still at a generational low. As workers get older and leave the workforce and there are fewer young people to fill those positions, society is going to wrestle with the fact that workforce participation may be in a long term trend to go lower rather than go higher. Factor in other elements such as lack of access to childcare and these problems just get worse. In other words, while it is easy to blame federal minimum wage legislation for driving up wages, it really seems to be market forces that are causing these wages to increase and this is going to be a long-term problem for smaller nonprofit organizations.
The nonprofit organizations that we all support are in the same boat when it comes to attracting and retaining talent. These organizations are under the same market struggles to meet payroll while serving individuals and will need to strategize for new ways to raise funds or collaborate with other nonprofits or for-profit entities if they are going to remain viable going into the future.
Minimum wage legislation undoubtedly aims to uplift workers and improve their standard of living. However, the impacts of these policies on small rural nonprofit organizations can’t be easily forgotten. While higher wages can benefit employees, the financial strain on these organizations may result in reduced services and limited capacity to address community needs. Finding a balance between fair compensation for workers and the sustainability of rural nonprofits is crucial to ensure the continued well-being and development of rural communities. Policymakers, nonprofits, and the community must collaborate to find innovative solutions that support both workers' rights and the essential work carried out by small rural nonprofit organizations.
The Weekly Notebook
A few notes and ideas of things I am seeing and hearing on the nonprofit world.
Our Other Publication is Growing!
I recently started a new substack that is focusing on my work here in my hometown of Troy, Ohio and it is growing like the grass in yard after the much needed rain this week! The Civic Capacity substack has been stewarding the positive energy that came from a close Mayoral election into productive conversations about our community. Even if you aren’t from the Troy community, I do believe you will find some interesting ideas and concepts about local government and I would love for you to be a part of the conversation we are having over there!
Please check it out and let me know what you think! You can find it here:
Now Hiring!
I have a nonprofit in Sidney, Ohio that has reached out to me looking for a new Executive Director. I can tell you that this a very strong organization that needs leadership that has strong entrepreneurial and staff management skills. If you have any interest, please drop me a line at pinnaclestrategiesltd@gmail.com and let’s talk!
If you or your nonprofit would like to advertise a job opening here, please shoot me an email at pinnaclestrategiesltd@gmail.com
How Can We Work Together?
Did you know that Pinnacle Strategies works individually with nonprofit and public sector leaders to help them solve problems, achieve goals and gain confidence in their roles?
Why?
Because, this work is hard and it’s often a lonely road. Our nonprofit and public sector leaders need people that they can talk to to get solid advice and encouragement to do the work that is in front of them. If you feel that this can be of value to you, or a member of your team, please reach out to pinnaclestrategiesltd@gmail.com and let’s talk.
Ready to Learn Something New?
One of the prettiest cities in the Midwest is Indianapolis and travelling there can open a perfect opportunity to sharpen your skills and meet new professionals in the field. I would encourage you to look at some of the offerings of The Fund Raising School at the Lilly School of Philanthropy at Indiana University’s campus in Indianapolis. The professional development school has great programming both on-line and in-person both in Indianapolis and at other sites across the country. Take a look at their course offerings here!
Online Learning Options from Texas A&M Announced
If travelling for professional development isn’t in the cards (or the budget), the Center for Nonprofits at Texas A&M University has some great offerings! I recently enrolled in one of their certificate programs and really enjoyed the online format and the online discussions that were developed. It was time and money well spent and I would highly recommend this program, especially for early or mid-career professionals. The next session begins in early February and you can learn more here!
Other Ways to Connect
Our coaching practice has openings and it has been a blast working with nonprofit leaders all across the country! If you are interested in working with me to get your nonprofit organization on a track to achieve the big missions you have, please reach out to me at pinnaclestrategiesltd@gmail.com.
Here are some other ways you can keep in contact with Pinnacle Strategies!
Check us out on our LinkedIn Page
Check us out on the Celebrating Leadership Facebook Page.
Want to help support this newsletter?
I hope you have found value in this newsletter. If you have found it valuable and want to help, the best thing you can do is “hit the heart”! By liking this post, you help other people interact with it. Also, sharing and commenting is very helpful as well. Thank you.